Skip to content
Design-Build vs Design-Bid-Build: Risk, Speed and Cost Compared
Owner guide

Design-Build vs Design-Bid-Build: Risk, Speed and Cost Compared

How the two main delivery methods divide responsibility, what published studies found about cost and schedule, and where construction management at risk fits in.
Quick answer

Design-build vs design-bid-build comes down to who carries design risk and when the builder joins. In design-bid-build the owner finishes the design with an architect and then bids it. In design-build one firm holds a single contract for design and construction. A 2018 study of 212 building projects found design-build faster with less cost growth.

Design-build vs design-bid-build: the definitions

Design-bid-build (DBB): The owner hires an architect to complete the design, then invites builders to bid on the finished documents and usually awards to the lowest responsive, responsible bidder. The owner holds two separate contracts, one with the designer and one with the builder.

Design-build (DB): The owner signs one contract with a design-build firm that is responsible for both design and construction. Florida's public procurement statute defines a design-build contract as a single contract with a design-build firm for the design and construction of a public construction project.

Construction management at risk (CMAR): The owner hires the architect and, separately and early, a construction manager who advises during design and then commits to a guaranteed maximum price and builds the project, holding the trade subcontracts.

Progressive design-build: A design-build variant in which the owner selects the design-builder mainly on qualifications, then develops the design and price together with it in stages before agreeing a contract price.

The Design-Build Institute of America describes the single contract as the fundamental difference between design-build and every other delivery system. Everything else, including who answers for design errors, when price becomes firm and how much control the owner keeps over details, follows from that structure.

Side-by-side comparison

Design-bid-build, design-build and CMAR compared
FeatureDesign-bid-buildDesign-buildCM at risk
Contracts the owner signsTwo: architect and builderOne: design-builderTwo: architect and construction manager
When the builder joinsAfter design is completeAt the startDuring design
Usual basis of builder selectionLowest responsive bidBest value or qualifications, then priceQualifications and fee, then GMP
When price becomes firmAt bid, on complete documentsAt contract or at an agreed design stageAt the GMP, often before documents are complete
Design control by ownerHighestLower; set through performance requirementsHigh; architect works for owner
Design and construction overlapNoneYesYes, through early packages
Who answers for design coordinationOwner, through the architectDesign-builderOwner, through the architect, with CM input
Typical AIA formsB101 and A101A141B101 and A133

General description of common practice. Contract terms decide actual responsibilities.

Source: [4][5][8]

No method is better in every column. Design-bid-build gives the owner the most direct control over design and a competitive price on a complete set of documents, but it is sequential and leaves the owner between the architect and builder when the drawings and the field disagree. Design-build gives one point of responsibility and lets design and construction overlap, but the owner gives up some control over detailed design choices and must define performance requirements well at the start.

Pre-engineered metal building frame going up on a slab
Illustrative photograph (generated image).

The A101, A133 and A141 document sets behind each method, with ConsensusDocs equivalents, are compared in our guide to AIA contract documents.

What the research found on cost and schedule

The best recent evidence for buildings is a 2018 study by Keith Molenaar of the University of Colorado Boulder and Bryan Franz of the University of Florida, funded by the Charles Pankow Foundation and the Construction Industry Institute. It analyzed 212 U.S. building projects completed over the prior ten years, 53 delivered by design-bid-build, 78 by construction management at risk and 81 by design-build, and used regression models to compare them while holding project characteristics constant.

Predicted performance differences, 212 U.S. building projects
MeasureDB vs CMARCMAR vs DBBDB vs DBBVariance explained (R2)
Unit cost1.9% less1.6% more0.3% less99%
Cost growth2.4% less1.4% less3.8% less22%
Schedule growth3.9% less2.2% more1.7% less21%
Construction speed13% faster20% faster36% faster88%
Delivery speed61% faster25% faster102% faster89%

Regression-predicted differences holding other variables constant. Projects completed after 2008: 53 DBB, 78 CMAR, 81 DB.

Source: [1]

Cost and schedule growth compared with design-bid-build

Predicted percent difference vs DBB; negative means lower than DBB

Cost and schedule growth compared with design-bid-buildBar chart comparing design-build and CMAR with design-bid-build: design-build unit cost 0.3% lower, cost growth 3.8% lower and schedule growth 1.7% lower; CMAR unit cost 1.6% higher, cost growth 1.4% lower and schedule growth 2.2% higher.-4-2024percent difference vs DBB-0.31.6Unit cost-3.8-1.4Cost growth-1.72.2Schedule growthDesign-build vs DBBCMAR vs DBB

Source: Molenaar and Franz, Revisiting Project Delivery Performance (Charles Pankow Foundation and CII, 2018)

On cost, the differences were small. Design-build projects were predicted to cost 0.3% less per square foot than design-bid-build and 1.9% less than CMAR, with 3.8% less cost growth than design-bid-build. On speed, the differences were large: design-build was 36% faster in construction and 102% faster over the whole project than design-bid-build. The authors note that, apart from delivery speed, the performance gap between the three methods has narrowed since the original 1998 CII study.

Speed compared with design-bid-build

Predicted percent faster than DBB

Speed compared with design-bid-buildBar chart: design-build was 36% faster in construction and 102% faster in total delivery than design-bid-build; CMAR was 20% faster in construction and 25% faster in delivery.025.050.075.0100125percent faster than DBB36.020.0Construction speed10225.0Delivery speed (design through completion)Design-build vs DBBCMAR vs DBB

Source: Molenaar and Franz, Revisiting Project Delivery Performance (Charles Pankow Foundation and CII, 2018)

Two caveats matter. The models explained 99% of the variation in unit cost but only 22% of the variation in cost growth, so the cost growth result is less certain. And the study also found that team chemistry, open-book payment terms and early builder involvement predicted good outcomes, which means a well-run project under any method can beat a badly run one under the favored method.

For highways, the Federal Highway Administration's 2006 Design-Build Effectiveness Study surveyed managers of projects under its SEP-14 program. They estimated that design-build cut project duration by 14 percent on average and total cost by 3 percent while keeping quality the same. FHWA's review of earlier building and highway studies found duration reductions ranging from 4 percent to 60 percent, and cost results ranging from an 18 percent reduction to a 23 percent increase. Treat the highway findings as context: they come from a different kind of project.

Highway managers' estimates of design-build impact

FHWA survey of SEP-14 design-build project managers, percent change vs design-bid-build

Highway managers' estimates of design-build impactBar chart of FHWA survey estimates: design-build changed project duration by an average of -14.1% (median -10.0%), total cost by -2.6% (median 0.0%) and quality by 0.0%.-15.0-10.0-505percent-14.1-10.0Project duration-2.60Total cost00QualityAverage estimateMedian estimate

Source: Federal Highway Administration, Design-Build Effectiveness Study, Final Report (January 2006), Exhibit 3

Who carries which risk

Delivery method is really a decision about risk. The table shows the usual allocation under standard forms, but your contract decides, so have it reviewed by a construction attorney before signing. This is a general description, not legal advice.

Usual risk allocation by delivery method
RiskDesign-bid-buildDesign-buildCM at risk
Errors and gaps in the drawingsMostly owner, through the architectDesign-builderMostly owner; CM review reduces it
Price rises before contractOwner until bidOwner until contract price is fixedOwner until GMP
Price rises after contractBuilder, within lump sumDesign-builder, within contract priceCM, within GMP
Unforeseen site conditionsUsually owner, per contractUsually owner, per contractUsually owner, per contract
Owner scope changesOwnerOwnerOwner
Coordination between design and fieldOwner manages two partiesDesign-builderShared; CM leads field

Typical outcomes under standard forms; individual contracts often shift these risks. Not legal advice.

Source: [4][8]

Design-bid-build tends to produce change orders where drawings are incomplete or conflict with site conditions, and the owner sits between the architect and the builder in those disputes. Design-build moves design coordination inside one firm, but if the owner's requirements are vague, the design-builder will meet them in the cheapest compliant way. CMAR sits between the two: the construction manager helps shape the design and then guarantees a maximum price, while the architect still works for the owner.

When each method fits

Design-bid-build fits when the design is straightforward, the owner wants full control over every detail, time is not critical and public rules require low-bid award. Examples include a standard retail shell, a repeat building type or a public project where the procurement law points to sealed bids.

Design-build fits when speed matters, the building type is well understood by the market and the owner can describe what it needs in performance terms. Warehouses, pre-engineered metal buildings and many light industrial projects are common candidates; see our pages on warehouse construction and metal building contractors. FMI's 2024 Design-Build Utilization Study, published through DBIA, expected the largest design-build investment in manufacturing, highway and street, and educational construction.

Construction management at risk fits when the owner wants its own architect and design control but also wants builder input, early pricing and a guaranteed maximum price, often on complex, phased or occupied projects such as hospitals and renovations.

  • How fixed is your scope today? The less fixed, the more you benefit from a builder at the table early.
  • How much do you care about controlling design details versus outcomes?
  • Is your opening date fixed by a lease, a season or a business launch?
  • Do you have in-house or hired expertise to write performance requirements and review a design-builder's work?
  • Does a public funding source or procurement law dictate the method?

CMAR as a third option

Construction management at risk keeps the architect under a separate contract with the owner and adds a construction manager during design. The CM prices design stages, flags constructability problems and then offers a guaranteed maximum price, usually on an open-book basis where savings below the GMP are shared or returned under the contract terms. AIA's A133 is the standard owner-construction manager agreement for this arrangement.

Florida's statutes recognize the model for public work. Under Fla. Stat. 255.103, a county, city, school district or special district may select a construction management entity through the competitive process in Fla. Stat. 287.055 and may require it to offer a guaranteed maximum price and a guaranteed completion date, in which case the entity must provide a surety bond and hold the construction subcontracts. Our construction management at risk page explains when private owners choose it.

In the 2018 study, CMAR projects were predicted to cost 1.6% more per square foot than design-bid-build, with 1.4% less cost growth, 2.2% more schedule growth, 20% faster construction and 25% faster delivery. That profile, a little more cost for more speed and more price certainty, is roughly what owners choose CMAR for.

How public owners procure design-build

Public rules show how a careful owner structures design-build selection. Federal agencies use the two-phase design-build selection procedures in FAR Subpart 36.3. In phase one, offerors are evaluated on technical approach, qualifications and past performance, with cost or price factors not permitted. The contracting officer then invites the most highly qualified offerors, normally no more than five, to submit technical and price proposals in phase two.

Florida public owners using design-build under Fla. Stat. 287.055 must have a design criteria package prepared and sealed by a design criteria professional, describing performance-based criteria for the project, and the design-build firm must be certified to contract through a licensed general or building contractor as qualifying agent. FHWA's study recommended that preliminary designs included in a request for proposals be no more than 30 percent complete, because agencies reported higher satisfaction when design-builders could still shape the design.

Private owners are free of these rules but can borrow them: shortlist on qualifications first, give the finalists a clear performance brief and compare both design and price. For federal work in your state, see our federal construction contracts by state report.

Project meeting table with a building model, schedule and material samples
Illustrative photograph (generated image).

How common is design-build?

Design-build has grown from an alternative method into a mainstream one. The 2018 Pankow study cites estimates that design-build's share of U.S. nonresidential construction rose from 24% in 1996 to 38% in 2014. FMI's 2024 study for DBIA forecasts that design-build will represent over 47% of U.S. construction spending by 2028, growing at a 2.9% compound annual rate. These are industry estimates rather than government statistics, and DBIA is an advocacy organization for the method, so read them as direction rather than precise shares. For total spending by building type, see the commercial construction spending tracker.

Running a design-build selection as a private owner

Private owners do not have to follow public procurement law, but the structure public agencies use is a good template. The aim is to compare firms on what matters before price takes over, then compare complete design-and-price packages from a short list.

  1. Write a performance brief.

    Describe the program, site, quality level, systems you require, budget ceiling and schedule. The clearer the brief, the less the design-builder has to guess and the easier the proposals are to compare.

  2. Consider an owner's representative or criteria architect.

    An independent architect or project manager can prepare the brief and review proposals, giving you design oversight you would otherwise lose.

  3. Shortlist on qualifications.

    Ask for comparable completed buildings, the proposed designer and key staff, bonding capacity and safety record, and invite a small number of firms to the second round.

  4. Request design and price proposals.

    Ask finalists for a concept design, a price or guaranteed maximum price, a schedule and a list of assumptions and exclusions.

  5. Compare value, not just price.

    Score design quality, operating cost, schedule and price together, then negotiate the contract on a standard form such as AIA A141.

  6. Keep review rights in the contract.

    Set design review points, approval rights for key systems and finishes, and how changes to your brief are priced.

Choosing a method for your project

Decide on the delivery method before you hire anyone, because it decides who you hire first. If you lean toward design-build, CB&C can introduce design-build contractors with in-house or partnered design teams. Whatever you choose, vet the firm with our contractor selection guide, test the budget with the cost per square foot guide, and see where the method changes the sequence in the commercial construction process. All owner guides are on the guides hub.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between design-build and design-bid-build?

The number of contracts. In design-bid-build the owner contracts separately with an architect and then a builder chosen by bid. In design-build the owner signs one contract with a firm responsible for both design and construction.

Is design-build cheaper than design-bid-build?

Not by much on unit cost. The 2018 study of 212 building projects predicted design-build would cost 0.3% less per square foot than design-bid-build, with 3.8% less cost growth. The bigger difference was speed.

Is design-build faster?

In the same study, design-build projects were 36% faster in construction and 102% faster from design through completion than comparable design-bid-build projects. Overlapping design and construction is the main structural reason owners choose it for speed.

What are the disadvantages of design-build?

The owner gives up some control over design details, needs clear performance requirements at the start, and has less independent design oversight unless it hires an owner's representative or criteria architect. Comparing proposals is also harder than comparing lump-sum bids.

When is design-bid-build the better choice?

When the design is straightforward, time is not tight, the owner wants full control over every detail, or public procurement rules require competitive sealed bids on complete documents.

How is construction management at risk different from design-build?

Under CMAR the owner keeps a separate contract with the architect and hires a construction manager during design who later commits to a guaranteed maximum price. Under design-build one firm holds both design and construction.

Can public agencies in Florida use design-build?

Yes. Fla. Stat. 287.055 sets procedures for public design-build contracts, including a design criteria package prepared by a design criteria professional, and requires the design-build firm to be certified through a licensed general or building contractor.

What is progressive design-build?

A form of design-build in which the owner chooses the design-builder mainly on qualifications and then develops the design and price with it step by step before agreeing a contract price. FMI's 2024 study notes it gaining ground in water and wastewater and health care projects.

Sources