Skip to content

Construction Contingency: How Much to Carry, Who Controls It and Who Keeps the Rest

Commercial office floor mid-renovation with new metal studs beside old walls and drawings on a plywood table

Construction contingency is money budgeted for costs that are expected but not yet assigned: federal GSA policy carries 7% for new buildings and 10% for renovations during construction, plus a design contingency that falls from 10% to 0%.

Key takeaways

  • The U.S. General Services Administration (GSA) sets construction contingency at 7% of the escalated award estimate for new capital construction and 10% for modernization and repair and alteration work (GSA P120, Table 3-1).
  • Design contingency is a separate line that shrinks as drawings mature: GSA carries 10% at planning, 5% to 7.5% at design development for new buildings and 0% at final construction documents (GSA P120).
  • Colorado state projects carry 5% of total project cost for new construction and 10% for renovation, and unspent contingency reverts to the capital construction fund (Colorado Office of the State Architect, Rev 8/2023).
  • Under AIA A133-2019 the construction manager’s contingency sits inside the guaranteed maximum price (GMP) “for the Construction Manager’s exclusive use” (§3.2.4), and any savings split is a blank the parties fill in at §6.1.7 (AIA A133-2019 text).
  • Ohio’s standard public CM-at-risk form returns 100% of unused CM contingency to the owner by default, plus a matching fee cut, no more than 30 days before final payment (Ohio OFCC Document 00 52 23, §3.4.1).
  • Escalation is a separate line in GSA’s method, priced to the midpoint of construction; BLS prices for new nonresidential buildings rose 5.4% in the 12 months to September 2026 (BLS PPI series WPU801).

What is construction contingency, and what is it not?

Construction contingency is a budgeted sum for unintended, not directly controllable events on a defined scope, such as unforeseen site conditions or design coordination gaps. GSA’s P120 cost and schedule policy (PBS 1000.6B, November 7, 2022) follows ASTM E2168 and separates it from allowances, which price planned items not yet defined, and reserves, which management holds for changed requirements. Owner-added scope is funded separately.

The split decides who may spend the money and what paperwork each draw needs. P120 also bars estimators from hiding a contingency inside unit prices or quantity takeoffs, so each of the 7 buckets below should appear as its own line in the estimate and, once a contract is signed, in the payment breakdown described in our guide to the schedule of values.

BucketWho holds itWhat it coversSize in public guidesSource
Design contingencyOwner’s estimator, inside the construction estimateElements expected but not yet drawn10% at planning down to 0% at final CDs, % of direct costGSA P120 Table 3-1
Escalation allowanceOwner’s estimatePrice rises from the estimate date to the construction midpointRate from a market study; BLS PPI +5.4% for the 12 months to September 2026BLS WPU801
Construction contingencyOwner, outside the contract sumChanges during construction: unforeseen site conditions, design coordination7% new, 10% renovation, % of ECCAGSA P120 Table 3-1
CM contingency (inside the GMP)Construction manager, for its exclusive useCosts inside the GMP not yet assigned to a line or change order2% of the trade subtotal, $382,211, in a 2018 North Carolina school GMPAIA A133 §3.2.4; Henderson County
AllowanceContract sum; owner selects the itemPlanned items not yet specified; the difference is settled by change orderSet item by itemAIA A201 §3.8
Owner contingencyOwner, at project levelWhole project: soft costs (design fees, permits, FF&E, financing) and constructionColorado: 5% new, 10% renovation of total project costColorado OSA
Management reserveOwner’s program or portfolioUnforeseen changes in requirements; not part of the construction estimateNot set as a percentageGSA P120
Where each construction contingency sits in an owner budget Nested boxes: owner contingency and soft costs sit beside the estimated cost of construction, which stacks direct cost, design contingency, escalation and construction contingency; a GMP holds the CM contingency. Where each contingency sits in the owner's budget Total project budget (owner) Owner contingency Held by the owner, outside the construction contract Colorado: 5% new, 10% renovation of total project cost Soft costs Design fees, permits, FF&E, financing Management reserve Program level: unforeseen changes in requirements (ASTM E2168 via GSA P120) Not part of the construction estimate Estimated cost of construction (ECC) Construction contingency 7% new, 10% renovation, % of ECCA (GSA) Escalation allowance Escalate to the construction midpoint Design contingency 10% at planning down to 0% at final CDs Direct cost of the work Includes allowances (AIA A201 §3.8) Inside a GMP CM contingency for the CM's exclusive use (A133 §3.2.4) Cost of the Work + CM Fee Owner pays nothing above the GMP (A133 §6.2) ECCA = direct cost + design contingency + escalation ECC = ECCA + construction contingency Source: GSA P120 (PBS 1000.6B), Table 3-1; AIA A133-2019
Design contingency, escalation and construction contingency stack inside the estimated cost of construction; the CM contingency sits inside a GMP and owner contingency outside it. GSA P120 Table 3-1; AIA A133-2019 §3.2.4. Accessed November 1, 2026.

GSA’s estimate terms make the stacking order explicit: ECCA = direct cost + design contingency + escalation, and ECC = ECCA + construction contingency. Because the 7% or 10% construction contingency is applied after escalation, it grows with the escalation rate. AIA A201-2017 §3.8 puts allowances inside the contract sum, with unloading, labor, overhead and profit priced outside the allowance figure; our AIA A201 guide covers that clause.

How much contingency do public owners carry?

Public owner manuals set construction-phase contingency at 5% to 10% for new buildings and 10% to 15% for renovations, but each applies the percentage to a different base. GSA uses the escalated award estimate, Colorado uses total project cost, and the University of Alaska Anchorage uses construction cost. Quote the base with the percentage, because 5% of total project cost and 5% of construction cost are different dollar amounts.

Owner and documentDateNew constructionRenovationBaseSource
GSA, P120 Table 3-1Nov 7, 20227%10%Estimated cost of construction at award (ECCA)GSA P120
GSA, cost estimating Q&A (Q8)Jan 18, 20247%10%“Determined by the level of Risk in a Project”GSA Q&A
DoD, UFS 3-701-01 Facilities Pricing Guide6 June 20265% (factor 1.05)Not set separatelyPlant replacement value formulaDoD UFS 3-701-01
Colorado Office of the State ArchitectRev 8/20235%10%Total project cost, excluding land or building purchaseColorado OSA
University of Arkansas, Policy 705.1First issued Dec 4, 200310% through bidding, no less than 5% at awardSame ruleConstruction costU of A 705.1
University of Alaska Anchorage, Appendix 7.4b2017About 10%12% to 15%Construction costUAA guidelines
Cornell University, Capital Project Financial GuidelinesNov 20253.5% on planned maintenance under $2MSame, with a $200,000 pooled fund behind itNot statedCornell guidelines
Washington Department of Enterprise ServicesNov 14, 2025Not set“Often exceeds 10%” on remodelsNot statedWA DES

The DoD figure works differently from the rest. The DoD Facilities Pricing Guide supplement of 6 June 2026 multiplies replacement value by 1.05 for construction contingencies, 1.057 for supervision, inspection and overhead in the continental U.S., and 1.09 for planning and design (1.13 for medical). It is a portfolio planning factor, not a project rule, and it matches Colorado’s 5% for new construction.

How does design contingency fall as drawings progress?

Design contingency covers expected but undrawn elements, so it shrinks as documents fill in. GSA’s Table 3-1 sets 10% at planning and development for both new and repair and alteration work, 7.5% to 10% at concept design for new buildings against 10% to 15% for renovation, and 0% once construction documents are final. These percentages apply to direct cost, before markups and escalation.

Design stageNew constructionRepair and alteration (R&A)Source
Planning and development10%10%GSA P120 Table 3-1
Concept design7.5% to 10%10% to 15%GSA P120 Table 3-1
Design development5% to 7.5%7.5% to 10%GSA P120 Table 3-1
75% construction documents2% to 5%3.5% to 7.5%GSA P120 Table 3-1
90% construction documents1% to 3%1.5% to 3.5%GSA P120 Table 3-1
Final construction documents0%0%GSA P120 Table 3-1
GSA design contingency by design stageLine chart: GSA design contingency peaks at 10% new and 15% renovation at concept design and falls to 0% at final CDs.0510.015.020.0%PlanningConcept designDesign development75% CDs90% CDsFinal CDsNew constructionRepair and alteration
GSA’s design contingency for renovation peaks at 15% at concept design, against 10% for new buildings, and both reach 0% at final construction documents. GSA P120 Table 3-1, accessed November 1, 2026.
Screenshot of GSA P120 Table 3-1 with the 7% new and 10% modernization construction contingency rows boxed
GSA P120 Table 3-1, page 19: construction contingency of 7% of ECCA for new capital construction and 10% for modernization (boxed). PBS 1000.6B, November 7, 2022, accessed November 1, 2026.

Washington State writes the same idea into its budget forms. Its 2025-27 capital budget instructions (June 2024) count the design contingency inside the maximum allowable construction cost (MACC) and keep project contingency outside it, so the design allowance is spent by the time the contractor’s price is set.

Why do renovations carry more contingency than new buildings?

Renovations carry more because existing buildings hide conditions that drawings cannot show. GSA adds 3 points at the construction stage (10% against 7%) and up to 5 points at concept design (15% against 10%). The University of Alaska Anchorage lifts renovations to 12% to 15%, and Washington DES notes remodel contingency often exceeds 10% because of unforeseen conditions and aging systems.

Colorado’s cost management guidelines list 5 kinds of change that its 10% renovation contingency is meant to absorb, and each one is more likely in an existing building:

  • Differing site conditions: found on site or in the structure and not detected in the initial investigations.
  • Bid alternates: additive or deductive alternates taken after the base bid result.
  • Added value: work needed to deliver the original scope that the bid documents omitted.
  • Upgrades: voluntary material or system upgrades within the original scope, justified on durability, energy or appearance.
  • Unknown items: disruptions, shutdowns and relocations caused by working around existing operations.

Washington DES also asks for a written narrative once changes pass 15% of the original contract cost, a useful tripwire for any owner. How occupied buildings are phased and priced is covered in our guide to commercial renovation contractors.

Is escalation part of construction contingency?

Treat escalation as its own line. GSA’s P120 calls escalation a contingency for future market and code-driven price increases, but prices it separately: the estimator escalates the current estimate to the midpoint of construction, assuming half the work is bought before that point, with a project market study as the primary data source. Construction contingency is then added to the escalated figure.

IndexPeriodChangeSource
BLS PPI, new nonresidential building construction (WPU801)Sep 2025 to Sep 2026 (preliminary)+5.4% (176.749 to 186.243)BLS
RLB National Construction Cost Index12 months to July 2026+4.45% (to 292.28)RLB Q3 2026
Mortenson Construction Cost Index12 months to Q3 2026+5.60%Mortenson Q3 2026

On a $4,620,000 estimate at concept design, 12 months to the construction midpoint at the BLS rate adds $248,161. Washington’s 2025-27 instructions require structured escalation research for projects over $25,000,000 and a formal report on cost and escalation drivers above $50,000,000. Monthly updates of these series are on our commercial construction price index.

Who controls contingency in a GMP contract, and who keeps the savings?

In a guaranteed maximum price contract two pots sit side by side. The construction manager’s contingency sits inside the GMP for its exclusive use under AIA A133-2019 §3.2.4, covering costs in the GMP not yet assigned to a line. The owner’s contingency sits outside the GMP and pays for owner changes by change order. Who keeps unspent CM contingency is whatever §6.1.7 or the owner’s form says.

QuestionAIA A133-2019Ohio OFCC K-12 CM at risk formColorado state projects
How the CM contingency is setStated in the GMP proposal with the cost of the work and fee (§3.2.1, §3.2.3.3)Proposed with the GMP Amendment, capped at a stated % of the Cost of the WorkProject contingency of 5% or 10% of total project cost
Who may draw itThe CM, for costs in the GMP not assigned elsewhere (§3.2.4)The CM, within the capThe agency, by category, never to add scope beyond the appropriation
Paper trailIts own schedule of values line (§11.1.5); supporting documents to the Architect for each transfer (§11.1.5.3)Not covered in the clause readContingency Summary Form at closeout
Cost above the GMPPaid by the CM without reimbursement (§6.2)Not covered in the clause readNot applicable
Unspent at closeoutOwner pays only the Cost of the Work plus the Fee (§6.1.1); a split needs §6.1.7100% returned by Shared-Savings Change Order, plus a fee cut (§3.4.1)Reverts to the capital construction fund

The arithmetic below uses the 3.75% fee and $382,211 CM contingency (2% of $19,110,546 in trade packages) from Henderson County, North Carolina’s 2018 Edneyville Elementary GMP (board packet, April 18, 2018), and assumes $120,000 is unspent at closeout. The unspent figure is an illustration, not a reported result.

Savings clauseOwner savesCM keepsArithmetic
Ohio §3.4.1 default$124,500$0$120,000 returned + 3.75% fee cut on $120,000 ($4,500)
A133, §6.1.7 blank, fee 3.75% of cost$124,500$0Unspent $120,000 is never billed; fee falls by $4,500
A133, §6.1.7 blank, lump-sum fee$120,000$0Fee does not change
A133 with a 50/50 split written into §6.1.7$60,000$60,00050% x $120,000, before any fee effect

A shared-savings clause gives the manager a reason to finish under the GMP, and the owner pays for that incentive: in the 50/50 row it costs $60,000. How the GMP itself is assembled, step by step, is set out in our guide to construction management at risk. Audit rights over the cost of the work are compared across AIA forms in our cost-plus contract guide.

How is contingency drawn down and released?

Contingency is spent through documented transfers and released in steps. Public manuals hold it high through bidding, cut it at award, track it against progress and return what is left at closeout. The University of Arkansas guideline (Policy 705.1) holds 10% through design and bidding and allows no less than 5% at award, and Colorado reverts unspent contingency to its capital construction fund.

How construction contingency is set, drawn and released Seven steps from setting contingency at budget to returning unused contingency at closeout. Contingency from budget to closeout 1 Set at budget Design + construction contingency by stage 2 Lock in the GMP CM contingency as its own line, capped 3 Bid and award 10% through bidding, no less than 5% at award 4 Document draws Support to the Architect for each transfer 5 Report monthly Remaining contingency vs percent complete 6 Partial release One release request after substantial completion 7 Return at closeout Shared-savings change order or reversion Sources: AIA A133-2019 §3.2.4, §11.1.5.3; Ohio OFCC §3.4.1; Univ. of Arkansas 705.1; Cornell (Nov 2025); Colorado OSA
Contingency is held at 10% through bidding, cut to no less than 5% at award, documented per transfer and returned at closeout. University of Arkansas 705.1; AIA A133-2019 §11.1.5.3; Ohio OFCC §3.4.1. Accessed November 1, 2026.
  1. Set at budget. Carry design + construction contingency by stage: GSA starts at 10% design contingency plus 7% or 10% construction contingency. Colorado splits the pot into professional services, construction, FF&E and miscellaneous.
  2. Lock in the GMP. Show the CM contingency as its own line, capped: A133 §3.2.3.3 lists it in the GMP proposal and §11.1.5 gives it a schedule of values line; Ohio caps it at a stated % of the Cost of the Work.
  3. Bid and award. Arkansas keeps 10% through bidding, no less than 5% at award. Colorado bars using construction contingency to cover a bid overage without first consulting the Office of the State Architect.
  4. Document draws. Under A133 §11.1.5.3 the CM sends support to the Architect for each transfer from contingency to another line; owner contingency moves only by change order.
  5. Report monthly. Compare remaining contingency vs percent complete on each payment application, which A133 §11.1.6 requires to show percentage of completion by portion of the work.
  6. Partial release. Cornell allows one release request after substantial completion for contingency no longer needed (Cornell, November 2025).
  7. Return at closeout. Ohio executes a shared-savings change order no more than 30 days before final payment; Colorado reverts any balance to the capital construction fund.

Step 6 ties to the substantial completion milestone, when punch list and closeout costs are the main exposure left; our guide to substantial completion lists what that certificate triggers.

What does contingency add to a new build versus a renovation?

On the same 20,000 square feet at concept design, a renovation can carry more contingency dollars than a new building that costs more. Using GSA’s upper-end percentages and the BLS escalation rate, contingency and escalation add 24.0% to a $4,200,000 new office and 33.3% to a $3,240,000 office renovation. This is CB&C arithmetic on published figures, not a quote.

LineNew build: 20,000 sq ft office, MiamiRenovation: 20,000 sq ft office fit-outBasis
Base hard cost$4,200,000$3,240,000RLB Q3 2026 Miami secondary office midpoint, $210/sq ft; Cushman & Wakefield 2026 U.S. fit-out average, $162/sq ft
Design contingency at concept design$420,000 (10%)$486,000 (15%)GSA P120 Table 3-1, upper end
Subtotal$4,620,000$3,726,000
Escalation, 12 months to midpoint$248,161$200,141BLS WPU801, x 1.0537
Estimated cost at award (ECCA)$4,868,161$3,926,141
Construction contingency$340,771 (7%)$392,614 (10%)GSA P120 Table 3-1
Construction budget (ECC)$5,208,932$4,318,755
Per square foot$260.45$215.94Divided by 20,000 sq ft
Contingency plus escalation$1,008,932 (24.0% of base)$1,078,755 (33.3% of base)
Contingency only$760,771 (18.1% of base)$878,614 (27.1% of base)
Contingency and escalation: new build vs renovationBar chart: renovation carries $486.0K design and $392.6K construction contingency vs $420.0K and $340.8K for the new build.0200400600$ thousands420486Design contingency248200Escalation to midpoint341393Construction contingencyNew build ($4.2M base)Renovation ($3.24M base)
The $3,240,000 renovation carries $878,614 of contingency, more than the $760,771 on the $4,200,000 new build. CB&C illustration using GSA P120 and BLS data, November 2026.

Soft costs, land and financing are excluded; Colorado’s method would add a further 5% or 10% of total project cost on top of those lines. The new-build rows use the same RLB range and GSA percentages as the budget example in our commercial construction cost per square foot guide.

What do common rules of thumb get wrong?

Several top-ranking guides, read in November 2026, quote 5% to 10% without naming a source or a base. The primary documents agree on direction, more for renovation and less as drawings mature, but differ on the base and on who keeps leftovers. 4 claims recur, and each needs a qualifier from the public record.

What several guides sayWhat the primary source saysSource
“5% to 10% of the total budget is typical”The base changes the dollars: GSA applies 7% to the escalated award estimate, Colorado applies 5% to total project cost, and a design contingency of up to 10% sits on top early in designGSA P120; Colorado OSA
“Contractor contingency covers escalation”GSA prices escalation separately, to the construction midpoint, before construction contingency is addedGSA P120
“Unused contractor contingency is commonly split 60/40 or 75/25”AIA A133-2019 leaves the split blank at §6.1.7; Ohio returns 100% to the owner; Colorado reverts all unspent contingencyAIA A133; Ohio OFCC
“Contingency pays for owner-requested changes”GSA funds scope changes by revising the project budget, not from construction contingency; A133 §3.2.2 sends changes in scope, systems or quality through a change orderGSA P120; AIA A133

Which contingency level fits your project?

Pick the percentage from the design stage and the type of work, then adjust for size and contract. The 9 thresholds below come from GSA, Washington State, Colorado, Cornell and the AIA forms. When bids land above budget, compare them line by line before touching contingency, using our checklist on how to compare construction bids.

IfThenSource
New building at planning or concept designCarry 10% design contingency plus 7% construction contingency on the escalated estimateGSA P120
Renovation or alteration at concept designCarry 10% to 15% design contingency plus 10% construction contingencyGSA P120
Older or occupied building with unknown structure or systemsBudget at the top of the range: UAA allows 12% to 15%; Washington DES sees remodels exceed 10%UAA; WA DES
Construction midpoint more than 12 months awayAdd a separate escalation line; 12 months at 5.4% adds about $54 per $1,000BLS WPU801
Project over $50,000,000Use a quantitative risk register and risk-based contingencyWA OFM 2025-27
Project from $10,000,000 to $50,000,000Use a formal qualitative risk registerWA OFM 2025-27
Signing a GMPShow CM contingency as its own line, cap it as a % of the Cost of the Work and fill in §6.1.7AIA A133; Ohio OFCC
Bids come in over budgetDo not spend construction contingency on the overage; take deductive alternates or redesign firstColorado OSA
Maintenance project under $2,000,0003.5% contingency backed by a pooled reserve, as Cornell doesCornell

This page summarizes 14 public owner documents and is not legal or financial advice; ask your attorney to check how contingency, allowances and the §6.1.7 savings clause are defined before you sign a GMP amendment.

Which party holds the contingency depends on the pricing method described in our guide to types of construction contracts.

Each draw on owner contingency is recorded on a signed G701, priced as shown in our change order guide with a worked example.

How we compiled this

We read 14 primary documents in October and November 2026: GSA’s P120 policy and its January 2024 Q&A, the DoD Facilities Pricing Guide supplement of 6 June 2026, capital budget guidance from Colorado, Washington State (OFM and DES), the University of Arkansas, the University of Alaska Anchorage and Cornell, the AIA A133-2019 and A201-2017 preview texts, Ohio’s CM-at-risk agreement form, a 2018 Henderson County GMP and the BLS producer price index. Hard costs come from 2 published cost reports (RLB Q3 2026 and Cushman & Wakefield 2026) and escalation from a third (Mortenson Q3 2026). Percentages in vendor blogs were excluded unless a primary document confirmed them, and the worked budget is labelled arithmetic, not market data.

Frequently asked questions

What is a typical construction contingency percentage?

Public owner guides set 5% to 10% for new construction and 10% to 15% for renovation, on different bases. GSA uses 7% for new capital construction and 10% for repair and alteration, applied to the escalated award estimate, plus a design contingency of up to 10% early in design. Colorado uses 5% and 10% of total project cost.

What is the difference between owner contingency and contractor contingency?

Owner contingency sits outside the construction contract and pays for owner changes and unknowns through change orders. Contractor or CM contingency sits inside the contract price or GMP: AIA A133-2019 §3.2.4 reserves it for the construction manager’s exclusive use, for costs that are in the GMP but not yet assigned to a line. Track the two separately.

What is the difference between a contingency and an allowance?

An allowance is a stated sum for a planned item not yet specified, such as door hardware, and AIA A201-2017 §3.8 adjusts the contract sum by change order when the actual cost differs. A contingency covers unplanned events. GSA’s P120, following ASTM E2168, requires the two to be shown separately and never hidden in unit prices.

What happens to unused construction contingency?

The contract decides. Under AIA A133-2019 the owner pays only the cost of the work plus the fee, so unspent CM contingency stays with the owner unless §6.1.7 sets a split. Ohio’s public form returns 100% plus a fee cut no more than 30 days before final payment, and Colorado reverts unspent contingency to its capital construction fund.

Is 10% contingency enough for a renovation?

Often, but not always. GSA uses 10% construction contingency for renovation once design is complete, plus up to 15% design contingency at concept design. The University of Alaska Anchorage allows 12% to 15% for renovations, and Washington’s Department of Enterprise Services notes that remodel contingency often exceeds 10% because of unforeseen conditions and aging systems.

Does contingency cover change orders?

It pays for change orders caused by unknowns, such as differing site conditions or coordination gaps, but not for added scope. GSA’s P120 says scope changes must be funded by revised project funding, not construction contingency, and AIA A133-2019 §3.2.2 sends changes in scope, systems or quality through a change order that adjusts the GMP.

Sources

Last reviewed November 2026 by the CB&C Editorial Team. See our editorial standards.

← Back to all articles