Skip to content
How to Choose a Commercial Contractor: Checks, Red Flags and a Scorecard
Owner guide

How to Choose a Commercial Contractor: Checks, Red Flags and a Scorecard

A practical sequence for owners: verify what the law requires, test what the paperwork cannot show, and compare bidders on a scored sheet instead of a gut feeling.
Quick answer

To learn how to choose a commercial contractor, work in order: confirm the state license covers your building, check insurance and bonding capacity, look up the firm's OSHA record, call owners of similar projects and level the bids line by line. In Florida, a contract signed by an unlicensed contractor cannot be enforced by that contractor.

How to choose a commercial contractor in five checks

Picking a builder for a commercial project is closer to hiring a business partner for a year than to buying a product. The contract will run to hundreds of pages, the builder will hold your money and your schedule, and the decision is hard to reverse once work starts. The safest approach is to separate the checks that can be verified from public records from the judgments that need conversations and site visits, and to do the verifiable ones first so you do not waste time interviewing firms that cannot legally do the work.

  1. Licensing.

    Confirm the firm, not just one person, holds a license that covers your building type and size in your state, and that it is current.

  2. Insurance and bonding.

    Get certificates of insurance and a letter from the surety confirming bonding capacity for a project of your size.

  3. Safety record.

    Search OSHA's inspection data by company name and ask about anything you find.

  4. References and comparable work.

    Speak to owners of two or three similar buildings, and visit one if you can.

  5. Bid levelling and scoring.

    Put every bid on the same scope basis, then score bidders on a weighted sheet.

CB&C runs the first two checks before introducing builders, as described on how we vet builders, but you should still repeat them yourself before signing. Licenses lapse and insurance policies get cancelled, and a check done months ago does not cover the day you sign.

Check that the license matches the work

Florida licenses construction contractors through the Construction Industry Licensing Board within the Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR). The license class matters as much as the license itself. Under Fla. Stat. 489.105, a certified general contractor may contract for any work that requires licensure, while a building contractor is limited to commercial buildings and residential buildings that do not exceed three stories, plus remodeling of any size that does not affect structural members. A residential contractor cannot build your commercial building at all.

Florida contractor license classes and commercial work
License classScope under Fla. Stat. 489.105Can build a commercial building?
General contractor (CGC certified, RG registered)Unlimited as to the type of work that requires licensureYes, any size or height
Building contractor (CBC certified, RB registered)Commercial and residential buildings not exceeding three stories; remodeling of any size that does not affect structural membersYes, up to three stories
Residential contractorOne-, two- and three-family residences of up to two habitable storiesNo
Specialty contractors (electrical, plumbing, mechanical, roofing and others)Their own trade onlyOnly their trade scope

Certified licenses apply statewide; registered licenses apply only where the holder has a local certificate of competency. Check the current statute and DBPR record before relying on this summary.

Source: [1][4]

Three rules in Chapter 489 matter most to owners. First, when a business organization contracts, it must have a licensed qualifying agent under Fla. Stat. 489.119, so look up the company and the qualifier. Second, the same statute requires the license number to appear on every bid, proposal, contract and advertisement, and building departments require it on each permit application. Third, under Fla. Stat. 489.128, a contract entered into by an unlicensed contractor cannot be enforced by that contractor, and no lien or bond claim exists in its favor. That protects owners, but it does not finish your building.

Use DBPR's licensee search to search by name or license number, and check that the status is current and active. Then read the license type: a certified license is valid statewide, while a registered license is tied to the local jurisdictions where the holder has a certificate of competency. Specialty work such as electrical, plumbing, mechanical and roofing is licensed separately, so ask which subcontractors the general contractor intends to use and check the main ones as well.

Outside Florida the rules differ widely. CB&C Research's 50-state review found 10 states with a state license and exam for commercial general contractors, 8 with a license above a dollar threshold, 12 with registration or a non-exam license and 20 that leave licensing to cities and counties. Florida's own minor-work exemption sits at $2,500. The full registry is in our commercial contractor licensing by state report.

How states license commercial general contractors

50 states and DC by licensing model, checked October 2026

How states license commercial general contractorsBar chart of licensing models for commercial general contractors: 20 jurisdictions leave licensing to localities, 12 use registration or a non-exam license, 10 use a state license with exam, 8 use a license above a dollar threshold and 1 was not verified.0510.015.020.025.0jurisdictions10.0State license withexam8Threshold-basedlicense12.0Registration ornon-exam20.0Local only1Not verified

Source: CB&C Research registry of state licensing boards and statutes, checked 2026-10-04

Insurance and bonding: what to ask for and why

Ask every finalist for certificates of insurance issued by the insurer or broker, not a photocopy from the contractor's file. Check the policy dates, the named insured (it should match the contracting entity), and the coverage types your contract will require: commercial general liability, workers' compensation, commercial auto and an umbrella or excess policy. Your attorney or insurance adviser should set the limits; the point here is to confirm the policies exist and run through the project dates.

Bonds work differently from insurance. A performance bond protects you if the contractor fails to finish, and a payment bond protects subcontractors and suppliers, which in turn protects your property from their liens. A surety underwrites the contractor's finances and track record before issuing a bond, so a letter confirming bonding capacity is also an independent signal about the firm's financial strength. AIA publishes standard forms for both: A310 for bid bonds and A312 for payment and performance bonds.

Where bonds are required by law on public work
RuleApplies toThresholdBonds
Miller Act, 40 U.S.C. 3131Federal construction, alteration or repair contractsMore than $100,000Performance bond and payment bond
Fla. Stat. 255.05, state workFlorida state public worksNot required at $100,000 or lessPayment and performance bond
Fla. Stat. 255.05, local workCounties, cities and other public authoritiesMay be exempted at $200,000 or lessPayment and performance bond
SBA Surety Bond GuaranteeSmall businesses using SBA-authorized suretiesGuarantee fee of 0.6% of contract priceBid, performance and payment bond guarantees
Private projectsAny private ownerSet by contractWhatever the contract requires

Summary of statutes and program pages as opened in October 2026. Not legal advice; thresholds change, so confirm with counsel for your project.

Source: [7][8][9]

On public work, bonds are often mandatory. The federal Miller Act requires performance and payment bonds on federal construction contracts; FAR 28.102-1 applies it to contracts above $150,000 after inflation adjustment, and Florida's Fla. Stat. 255.05 sets the state's rules for public works bonds, with no bond required on state contracts of $100,000 or less and local governments allowed to exempt contracts of $200,000 or less. Private owners can require bonds by contract. Smaller contractors who cannot get bonded through standard sureties can use the SBA Surety Bond Guarantee program, which charges a fee of 0.6% of the contract price for performance and payment bond guarantees.

Even without a payment bond, Florida law gives owners tools against double payment. Under Fla. Stat. 713.06, when final payment becomes due the contractor must give the owner a final payment affidavit listing any lienors who served a notice to owner and have not been paid. Make the affidavit and lien releases a condition of each payment. Deadlines vary by state; our mechanics lien laws by state registry lists them.

Insurance and bond paperwork prepared for a commercial contractor review
Illustrative photograph (generated image).

Liability certificates are only half the insurance check: under AIA A101-2017 Exhibit A the owner usually buys the property cover on the work, which our builder's risk insurance guide explains clause by clause.

If you are hiring an adviser rather than a builder, the checks differ: our page on vetting construction management companies covers licenses, E&O limits and the CCM credential.

A certificate of insurance confers no rights on its holder, so ask for the endorsement pages described in our guide to additional insured endorsements.

Owners set the per-occurrence and aggregate limits in the contract itself; our guide to general liability insurance for contractors shows the limits Caltrans and AIA owners set and the exclusions to look for.

Look up the contractor's safety record

OSHA publishes its inspection and citation records, and you can search them by establishment name on OSHA's data portal. Search every legal name the firm has used, note any serious, repeat or willful citations, and ask the contractor what changed afterwards. A single citation on a large firm is not unusual; a pattern of repeat fall-protection citations is a different story.

For context, federal OSHA issued 1,145 citations to nonresidential building contractors in fiscal year 2024, from 525 inspections that produced a citation, with an average penalty of $4,730 per citation. Fall protection was the most cited standard, but commercial building citations were more spread out than residential ones, with scaffolds, ladders, respiratory protection and silica close behind.

Most cited OSHA standards in nonresidential building construction, FY2024

Federal OSHA citations, NAICS 2362

Most cited OSHA standards in nonresidential building construction, FY2024Horizontal bar chart of the 12 OSHA standards most cited in nonresidential building construction in fiscal year 2024: duty to have fall protection 163 citations, scaffolds 119, ladders 58, respiratory protection 56, silica 53, general safety provisions 50, fall protection systems 48, aerial lifts 45, electrical wiring 37, excavation 34, hazard communication 29 and fall protection training 28.citationsFall protection, duty to have (1926.501)163Scaffolds, general (1926.451)119Ladders (1926.1053)58.0Respiratory protection (1910.134)56.0Respirable crystalline silica (1926.1153)53.0General safety and health (1926.20)50.0Fall protection systems criteria (1926.50248.0Aerial lifts (1926.453)45.0Electrical wiring methods (1926.405)37.0Excavation requirements (1926.651)34.0Hazard communication (1910.1200)29.0Fall protection training (1926.503)28.0

Source: OSHA Frequently Cited OSHA Standards, NAICS 2362, Federal, FY2024 (archived Nov. 2024), via CB&C Research

Penalties set a floor on how seriously a contractor should take this. For 2026, OSHA's maximum penalty is $16,550 per serious violation and $165,514 per willful or repeat violation. Ask finalists for their written safety program, how they hold subcontractors to it, who the site safety lead will be and how incidents are reported to you. Our OSHA violations in commercial construction report breaks the citations down further, and the construction safety article describes what good practice looks like on site.

References and comparable projects

Ask for projects similar to yours in building type, size, contract value and delivery method, completed in the last few years, and for the owner's contact rather than the architect's. The American Institute of Architects publishes a standard Contractor's Qualification Statement, AIA Document A305, which collects organization, experience, financial and legal information in one format and makes firms easier to compare.

  • Did the project finish on the date in the contract, and if not, why?
  • How many change orders were there, and were they priced fairly and quickly?
  • Who was the superintendent, and would you want the same person again?
  • How did the contractor handle a problem the drawings did not anticipate?
  • Were subcontractors and suppliers paid on time, and did any liens appear?
  • How complete were the closeout documents, warranties and as-built drawings?
  • Would you hire this contractor again for the same kind of building?

Ask who will actually run your job. The project manager and superintendent named in the proposal matter more than the firm's brochure, so ask for their resumes, the projects they ran and whether the contract can name them as key personnel. If the firm will self-perform work such as concrete or framing, ask to see one of those crews on a live site.

Bid levelling: comparing like with like

Bids rarely arrive on the same basis. One bidder includes site work, another lists it as an exclusion; one carries a generous allowance for finishes, another a thin one. Bid levelling means rebuilding each bid onto one scope so the totals can be compared. Our guide to comparing construction bids walks through the spreadsheet; the main steps are below.

  1. Issue one scope.

    Every bidder prices the same drawings, specifications, addenda and bid form.

  2. List exclusions and clarifications.

    Put each bidder's exclusions side by side and price the gaps so every bid covers the same work.

  3. Normalize allowances.

    Replace each bidder's allowances with one figure per item so a low allowance does not make a bid look cheaper.

  4. Separate alternates.

    Compare base bids first, then each alternate on its own.

  5. Compare general conditions and fee.

    These show how the firm staffs and runs the job, and they reveal unrealistic schedules.

  6. Interview the low bidder.

    A bid well below the others often means a missed scope item; ask the bidder to confirm it in writing.

Delivery method changes what you are comparing. Under design-bid-build you compare lump sums on finished drawings; under construction management at risk or design-build you often select on qualifications and fee before the price is fixed. Our guide to design-build vs design-bid-build and the page on construction management at risk explain how selection works for each, and our cost per square foot guide helps you sanity-check the totals.

Red flags that should stop the process

  • No license number on the bid or contract, or a license in a different name from the contracting company.
  • A request that you pull the permit yourself as an owner-builder on a project above the exemption.
  • A large deposit demanded before permits are issued or materials are ordered, with no schedule of values.
  • Certificates of insurance that the contractor will not let the broker send directly, or policies that expire mid-project.
  • No surety letter on a project where you asked for bonds, or a bond from a surety you cannot verify.
  • Vague scope with many open allowances, or a price far below the other bidders without explanation.
  • No named superintendent, or reluctance to put key personnel in the contract.
  • Resistance to lien waivers, a final payment affidavit or a written change order process.
  • References that are all from architects or friends rather than owners of similar buildings.

If something does not add up, you can report licensing concerns to DBPR, and if a builder introduced through CB&C behaves badly, tell us through report a concern.

A contractor that will not deliver conditional and unconditional waivers from its subcontractors with each pay application is a red flag; our lien waiver guide explains the four forms.

Contractor selection checklist

  • License verified today. Company and qualifier, correct class, active status, number printed on the bid.
  • Certificates of insurance received from the broker. Named insured matches the contracting entity, dates cover the project.
  • Surety letter on file. Bonding capacity covers your contract value, surety identified.
  • OSHA search done. Every legal name searched, citations discussed with the contractor.
  • Three owner references called. Similar building type, size and delivery method.
  • Key personnel named. Project manager and superintendent interviewed.
  • Bids levelled. Exclusions priced, allowances normalized, alternates separated.
  • Payment protections agreed. Schedule of values, retainage, lien releases and final payment affidavit.
  • Contract form chosen. Standard AIA or ConsensusDocs form, reviewed by your attorney.

A scored evaluation template

Once the pass or fail checks are done, score the remaining bidders. The template below is a starting point, not a standard: change the weights to match your priorities, and agree them before you open the bids so the price does not shape the weights. Score each criterion from 1 to 5, multiply by the weight and add up the column for each bidder.

Template: weighted contractor scorecard (example weights, adjust to your project)
CriterionWeightWhat scores 5What scores 1Bidder A (1 to 5)Bidder B (1 to 5)
Relevant experience25%Several completed buildings of the same type and size, owner references confirmNo comparable buildings
Levelled price25%Lowest levelled total with no unexplained gapsHighest levelled total or large unexplained gaps
Project team20%Named superintendent and project manager with comparable jobs, committed in contractTeam not named
Schedule and approach15%Credible schedule with long-lead items and permit time shownNo schedule or unrealistic dates
Safety record and program10%Clean OSHA history, written program, site safety lead namedRepeat or willful citations without explanation
Communication and reporting5%Clear reporting plan, responsive during biddingSlow or incomplete answers during bidding
Weighted total100%

Example weights chosen by CB&C for illustration. Licensing, insurance and bonding are pass or fail checks done before scoring.

Keep the scoring notes. If the decision is questioned later by a lender, a board or a partner, a written score sheet shows how you got there. The same structure works for interviews of design-builders or construction managers, with price replaced by fee and general conditions.

Commercial jobsite with guarded scaffolding and an organized laydown area
Illustrative photograph (generated image).

Where this fits in your project

Contractor selection usually happens after early design and before permitting, though under design-build it comes first. The commercial construction process guide shows where it falls, the commercial building permits guide covers what your builder will file, and the guides hub lists the rest. If you are planning new commercial construction or a commercial renovation, CB&C can introduce licensed builders who fit the project.

Trade licenses follow their own rules; our guide to hiring a commercial plumbing contractor lists the plumbing license classes in Florida, Texas, California, North Carolina and Virginia.

Frequently asked questions

How do I check a commercial contractor's license in Florida?

Use the DBPR licensee search at myfloridalicense.com and search by company name, person or license number. Check that the status is current and active, that the license class covers your building, and that the company has a licensed qualifying agent.

What is the difference between a general contractor and a building contractor in Florida?

Under Fla. Stat. 489.105, a general contractor's scope is unlimited for work requiring a license. A building contractor is limited to commercial and residential buildings that do not exceed three stories, plus remodeling of any size that does not affect structural members.

What happens if I hire an unlicensed contractor?

In Florida, Fla. Stat. 489.128 makes the contract unenforceable by the unlicensed contractor, who also has no lien or bond claim. The owner still faces practical risks: permits, inspections, insurance gaps and work that may have to be redone.

Should I require a performance and payment bond on a private project?

Bonds are only mandatory by law on certain public work, but private owners can require them by contract. They protect against non-completion and unpaid subcontractors, and the surety's underwriting is an independent check on the contractor's finances. Discuss the cost and terms with your attorney.

How do I look up a contractor's OSHA violations?

Search the company's legal names in OSHA's establishment search on osha.gov. The record shows inspections, citations and penalties. Ask the contractor to explain any serious, repeat or willful citations and what changed afterwards.

How many bids should I get for a commercial project?

Private work has no legal minimum. Invite enough prequalified firms for real competition, but not so many that good builders decline because their odds look poor. What matters more is that every bidder prices the same scope so the bids can be levelled.

Should I always pick the lowest bid?

No. Level the bids first, because a low total often reflects a missed scope item or a thin allowance. Then score price alongside experience, team, schedule and safety, as in the template on this page.

What documents should a commercial contractor give me before I sign?

A license number, certificates of insurance from the broker, a surety letter if bonds are required, a qualification statement such as AIA A305, references, a schedule, a schedule of values and the names of the project manager and superintendent.

Sources