Skip to content

Concrete Slump Test: How It Is Done, Target Ranges and What Happens When a Truck Fails

Ready-mix truck chute discharging fresh concrete at a commercial slab pour

A concrete slump test measures how far fresh concrete sags after a 12 inch cone is lifted: most commercial mixes are specified at 3 to 5 inches, read to the nearest 1/4 inch under ASTM C143.

Key takeaways

How is the concrete slump test done?

The concrete slump test is run on a sample taken under ASTM C172, started within 5 minutes of sampling, and finished within 2 1/2 minutes. A technician fills a dampened steel cone in three layers, rods each layer 25 times, lifts the cone straight up in about 5 seconds and measures the drop. The procedure below follows the WAQTC field operating procedure for AASHTO T 119-23, the highway twin of ASTM C143.

  1. Sample the load from the middle of discharge (ASTM C172). If the mix has aggregate over 1 1/2 in (37.5 mm), wet-sieve it first. Start testing within 5 minutes.
  2. Dampen the inside of the mold and set it on a flat, rigid, nonabsorbent, dampened base. Stand on both foot pieces.
  3. Fill to 1/3 of the volume, about 2 5/8 in (67 mm) deep. Rod 25 times through the full depth, starting near the perimeter with the rod slightly tilted, then spiraling to the center.
  4. Fill to 2/3 of the volume, about 6 1/8 in (155 mm) deep. Rod 25 times, entering about 1 in (25 mm) into the first layer.
  5. Overfill the mold. Rod 25 times, about 1 in into the second layer, topping up so concrete always stays above the rim.
  6. Strike off the top with a screeding and rolling motion of the rod and clean concrete from around the base.
  7. Lift the mold 12 in (300 mm) straight up in 5 ± 2 seconds with no twist. From the start of filling to this point, no more than 2 1/2 minutes.
  8. Set the empty mold upside down next to the concrete, lay the rod across it and measure to the displaced original center of the top surface, to the nearest 1/4 in (5 mm).
Dimensioned slump cone and rodSlump cone 12 in tall, 8 in base, 4 in top; three layers rodded 25 times; rod 5/8 in; timing and measuring rules.Slump cone, rod and fill layers (ASTM C143 / AASHTO T 119)Flat, rigid, nonabsorbent, dampened baseBase: 8 in (200 mm) diameterTop: 4 in (100 mm)12 in (300 mm)Layer 1: 1/3 by volume,about 2 5/8 in (67 mm) deep,25 strokes through full depthLayer 2: 2/3 by volume,about 6 1/8 in (155 mm) deep,25 strokes, 1 in into layer 1Layer 3: overfill the mold,25 strokes, 1 in into layer 2,keep excess on top, strike offTamping rod5/8 in (16 mm) dia.16 to 24 in longhemispherical tipStart within 5 min of sampling. Lift 12 in in 5 ± 2 s. Fill to lift in 2 1/2 min.Measure rod-to-displaced-center drop to the nearest 1/4 in (5 mm).
The slump cone is 12 in tall with an 8 in base and 4 in top, filled in 3 layers of 25 strokes and lifted in 5 ± 2 s. Sources: AASHTO T 119 FOP (WSDOT, January 2026); U.S. Navy Builder manual; accessed November 9, 2026.
ItemDimension or limitSource
Cone height12 in (300 mm)U.S. Navy Builder manual; ASTM C143
Cone base diameter8 in (200 mm)U.S. Navy Builder manual; ASTM C143
Cone top diameter4 in (100 mm)U.S. Navy Builder manual; ASTM C143
Tamping rod5/8 in (16 mm) diameter, 16 to 24 in long, hemispherical tipAASHTO T 119 FOP (2025)
Layers and strokes3 layers, 25 strokes eachAASHTO T 119 FOP (2025)
Layer 1 and 2 depthAbout 2 5/8 in (67 mm) and 6 1/8 in (155 mm)AASHTO T 119 FOP (2025)
Start after samplingWithin 5 minutesAASHTO T 119 FOP (2025)
Mold lift12 in in 5 ± 2 secondsAASHTO T 119 FOP (2025)
Fill to lift, total2 1/2 minutesAASHTO T 119 FOP (2025)
Read toNearest 1/4 in (5 mm)AASHTO T 119 FOP (2025)
Maximum aggregate1 1/2 in (37.5 mm), larger is sieved outASTM C143/C143M section 4.2

The current edition is ASTM C143/C143M-26b, listed as active on the ASTM store page (updated August 2026). Ask the testing agency which edition its technicians follow. TxDOT Item 421 section 4.8.1 requires testers to hold ACI certification or a recognized equivalent, and the WAQTC exam checklist is derived in part from ACI CP-1.

How do you read a true, shear or collapse slump?

Only a true slump, where the concrete settles evenly and keeps a rough cone shape, is a valid result. If one side shears off or falls away, AASHTO T 119 says to discard the test and run a new one on another portion of the sample. Two shears in a row mean the mix lacks the cohesion the test needs, per the T 119 FOP Note 1.

Slump result typesTrue, zero, shear and collapse slump shapes with the action each one triggers.Four slump shapes and what to do with eachmold topslumpTrue slumpValid: record itMass subsides evenly,keeps a cone shapemold topZero slumpBelow 1/2 in (15 mm):may not be plastic enoughfor the test to mean muchmold topShear slumpInvalid: retest onanother portion; 2 in a row= mix lacks cohesionmold topCollapseAbove about 9 in (230 mm):too fluid for slump; useslump flow (ASTM C1611)Limits from ASTM C143/C143M Significance and Use notes; retest rule from AASHTO T 119 (WAQTC FOP, 2025).
Only a true slump counts; a shear is retested on another portion, and slumps under 1/2 in or over about 9 in fall outside the test’s useful range. Sources: ASTM C143/C143M; AASHTO T 119 FOP; accessed November 9, 2026.
Result shapeWhat it meansWhat to doSource
True slumpMass subsides evenlyRecord to the nearest 1/4 inAASHTO T 119 FOP
Zero or near-zero slump (under 1/2 in)May not be plastic enough for the test to be meaningfulUse the consistency test the spec names for stiff mixesASTM C143 Note 2
Shear slumpOne side slides offDiscard; retest on another portion. Two in a row: mix lacks cohesionAASHTO T 119 FOP Note 1
Collapse (over about 9 in)Too fluid to hold shapeUse slump flow, ASTM C1611, for self-consolidating concreteASTM C143 Note 2; UFGS 03 30 00 3.14.3.2

ASTM C143 warns that slumps under 1/2 in (15 mm) may not be adequately plastic and slumps over about 9 in (230 mm) may not be cohesive enough for the number to mean much (ASTM C143/C143M Significance and Use). The same section says slump tracks water content in the lab, but the link to strength is not clearly shown in the field, so slump never replaces cylinders.

What slump should concrete have for each element?

Most commercial concrete is ordered at 3 to 5 inches of slump, per NRMCA CIP 31 (2023). Slip-form paving needs 2 inches or less, while walls, pumped mixes and congested rebar may need 7 to 9 inches. The project specification, written by the engineer, is the number that governs; the table shows typical published ranges.

Element or useSlump range, inSource
Default when the spec is silent4 (3 to 5 with tolerance)ACI 301-20 4.2.2.2; ACI 117-10
Most applications3 to 5NRMCA CIP 31 (2023)
Slip-form construction2 maximumNRMCA CIP 31 (2023)
Walls, pumped concrete, congested reinforcement7 to 9NRMCA CIP 31 (2023)
Walls over 9 in thick, caps, columns, piers3 to 7TxDOT 2024 Item 421 Table 9
Bridge slabs, approach slabs, overlays3 to 6TxDOT 2024 Item 421 Table 9
Inlets, manholes, walls under 9 in, barrier, formed pavement4 to 6TxDOT 2024 Item 421 Table 9
Precast concrete4 to 9TxDOT 2024 Item 421 Table 9
Underwater placements6 to 8 1/2TxDOT 2024 Item 421 Table 9
Footings and toppings (federal guide spec option)6 maximumUFGS 03 30 00 2.5.1 table
Any target slump on federal work9 maximumUFGS 03 30 00 2.5.1 d
Slump ranges by elementHorizontal range bars of placement slump in inches by element from TxDOT, NRMCA and ACI.Placement slump ranges by element, inches012345678910Slip-form paving (NRMCA CIP 31)0 to 2ACI 301 default, 4 in with ACI 117 tolerance3 to 5Most applications (NRMCA CIP 31)3 to 5Bridge slabs, approach slabs (TxDOT)3 to 6Walls over 9 in, caps, columns, piers (TxDOT)3 to 7Inlets, thin walls, barrier, formed paving (TxDOT)4 to 6Precast concrete (TxDOT)4 to 9Underwater placements (TxDOT)6 to 8.5Walls, pumped or congested steel (NRMCA)7 to 9Sources: TxDOT 2024 Item 421 Table 9; NRMCA CIP 31 (2023); ACI 301-20 4.2.2.2 and ACI 117-10.
Published placement slumps run from 2 in maximum for slip-form paving to 4 to 9 in for precast. Sources: TxDOT 2024 Item 421 Table 9; NRMCA CIP 31 (2023); ACI 301-20; accessed November 9, 2026.

Older mix-design tables in ACI 211.1, now published as ACI PRC-211.1-22, list maximum and minimum slumps by construction type and note that air entrainment usually permits lower slumps for the same placing job. Higher slump through a water reducer is a different matter: TxDOT Item 421 section 4.2.5 lets a mix exceed Table 9 with admixtures only if the w/cm stays the same or lower and the concrete does not segregate. To pick the strength class that goes with these slumps, see our guide to concrete psi by element.

What slump tolerance do ACI 117 and ASTM C94 allow?

A target slump of 4 inches or less carries a ±1 inch tolerance under ACI 117, and anything over 4 inches carries ±1 1/2 inches. ASTM C94, the ready-mix purchase standard, splits the target band more finely and adds a separate rule for slumps written as a maximum. Ask the engineer which standard and edition the spec names before the first pour.

How slump is specifiedSpecified slumpToleranceSource
Target (ACI 117)4 in or less±1 inACI 117-10
Target (ACI 117)Over 4 in±1 1/2 inACI 117-10
Target (ASTM C94)2 in or less±1/2 inASTM C94/C94M
Target (ASTM C94)Over 2 in through 4 in±1 inASTM C94/C94M
Target (ASTM C94)Over 4 in±1 1/2 inASTM C94/C94M
Maximum or “not to exceed” (ASTM C94)3 in or less+0, minus 1 1/2 inASTM C94/C94M
Maximum or “not to exceed” (ASTM C94)Over 3 in+0, minus 2 1/2 inASTM C94/C94M

Worked example: a spec reads “4 in slump, tolerances per ACI 117.” The acceptance window is 3 to 5 in, so a 5 1/4 in reading fails and a 3 in reading passes. If the same spec read “4 in maximum” under ASTM C94/C94M, the window becomes 1 1/2 to 4 in. The ready-mix producer is responsible for the specified slump for 30 minutes after the requested time or the truck’s arrival, whichever is later (NRMCA CIP 31).

How often should slump be tested on a commercial job?

Commercial specifications tie slump testing to strength sampling: at least once a day per mix, once per 150 cubic yards and once per 5,000 square feet of slab or wall, plus at the start of placement. That is the federal rule in UFGS 03 30 00 and the strength-test frequency in ACI 318-19 section 26.12.2.1 and ACI 301.

TriggerSlump test requiredSource
Start of placementYes, first loadUFGS 03 30 00 3.14.3.1
Each time strength cylinders are madeYesUFGS 03 30 00 3.14.3.1
Strength samples, per mixAt least 1 per day, 1 per 150 yd3, 1 per 5,000 ft2 of slab or wall; 5 sets minimum per projectUFGS 03 30 00 3.14.3.4
Optional volume intervalEvery [X] yd3, filled in by the designerUFGS 03 30 00 3.14.3.1
Pumped concreteSample at pump inlet and hose discharge; slump loss in the line 2 in maximumUFGS 03 30 00 3.7.2
Air content (air-entrained mixes)Same frequency as slumpUFGS 03 30 00 3.14.3.5
Hot or cold weather (below 50 °F or above 80 °F)Temperature every batch or every 20 yd3, and whenever slump is testedUFGS 03 30 00 3.14.3.3

Worked example: a 400 yd3 suspended deck of 18,000 ft2 placed in one day needs at least 4 strength samples by area (18,000 / 5,000 = 3.6, rounded up) and 3 by volume (400 / 150 = 2.7, rounded up), so the higher count, 4, governs, each with a slump test, plus the first-truck test. Put the frequency in the testing agency’s scope during submittal review, so nobody argues about it on pour day.

What should you do when a truck fails the slump test?

A load that tests high gets one check test on a fresh sample; if that also fails, the federal spec rejects it. A load that tests low may be brought up with withheld water or an admixture, mixed 30 drum revolutions and retested, and a second failure is a rejection. TxDOT lets a contractor keep over-slump concrete at its own risk with extra cylinders.

Failed slump decision flowchartDecision path for a load whose slump is too high or too low, from UFGS, NRMCA CIP 26 and TxDOT Item 421.Truck fails the slump test: what happens nextAcceptance slump (C172 sample, C143)Within spec slump plus tolerance?YesAccept and placeToo highCheck test on a newsample (UFGS 3.14.3.1)Check fails: reject, orTxDOT: use at contractor’soption with extra cylindersToo lowMore than about 1/4 yd3already discharged?YesNo water allowed;admixture only ifthe spec permitsNoTrim water on ticket andw/cm below the maximum?NoWater reducer ifapproved, else rejectYesAdd about 1 gal/yd3 per 1 in,record it on the ticket,30 drum revolutions, retestRetest fails: reject the loadAlso reject past the discharge limit: TxDOT 45 to 120 min by temperature; UFGS 90 min.
A high slump gets one check test; a low slump may take recorded trim water and 30 revolutions before more than about 1/4 yd3 is discharged. Sources: UFGS 03 30 00 (2025); NRMCA CIP 26 (2023); TxDOT Item 421 (2024); accessed November 9, 2026.
IfThenSource
Slump above spec plus toleranceRun a check test on a new sample; if it fails, the load failsUFGS 03 30 00 3.14.3.1
Over-slump on a TxDOT jobMay be used at contractor’s option; the Engineer makes and tests strength specimensTxDOT Item 421 4.8.3
Slump below spec, under about 1/4 yd3 discharged, trim water on ticketAdd measured water, 30 revolutions at mixing speed, retestNRMCA CIP 26; ASTM C94
Slump below spec, w/cm already at maximumNo water; water-reducing admixture only if approvedNRMCA CIP 26; TxDOT Item 421 4.2.5
Still low after all withheld waterRejected unless the Engineer allowsTxDOT Item 421 4.8.3
Discharge not started in timeReject: TxDOT 45, 60 or 90 min at 90 °F and above, 75 to 89 °F, under 75 °F (75, 90, 120 min with Type B or D admixture); UFGS 90 minTxDOT Item 421 Table 14; UFGS 03 30 00 3.6.2
Segregation or excess bleeding seenReject regardless of slumpTxDOT Item 421 4.8.3
Maximum time from batching to start of discharge, TxDOT Item 421Bar chart: TxDOT discharge limits of 45, 60 and 90 minutes rise to 75, 90 and 120 minutes with a retarding admixture.050.0100150minutes45.075.090 °F and above60.090.075 to 89 °F90.0120Below 75 °FWithout Type B or D admixtureWith Type B or D admixture
Hot concrete must start discharging sooner: TxDOT allows 45 minutes at 90 °F and above but 90 minutes below 75 °F, 30 minutes more with a Type B or D admixture. Source: TxDOT Item 421 Table 14 (2024), accessed November 9, 2026.

Write the rejection on the delivery ticket with the time, slump reading and technician name, and record it in the daily report. If the rejected load leads to a dispute over cost or schedule, the paper trail feeds a change order or back-charge, and an unclear spec clause belongs in an RFI before the next pour.

How does water added at the site change slump and strength?

Adding about 1 gallon of water per cubic yard raises slump about 1 inch, per NRMCA CIP 26 (2023). Water beyond the design amount delays set, cuts strength and raises cracking risk, and if the buyer asks for it, the buyer owns the result. ASTM C94 permits jobsite water only within the specified slump and w/cm, followed by 30 drum revolutions at mixing speed.

StepInputResult
Specified slump4 in target, ACI 117 ±1 inAcceptable 3 to 5 in
Measured on a preliminary sample after the first 1/4 yd32 1/2 in1/2 in below the window
Aim for4 inIncrease needed: 1 1/2 in
Rule of thumb1 gal per yd3 per 1 in1.5 gal per yd3
Load size10 yd315 gal total
Trim water held back on ticket20 gal (example)15 gal is within the limit; w/cm not exceeded
Mix and retest30 revolutions at mixing speedAcceptance test on a C172 sample

CIP 26 adds four controls: measure every gallon and record it on the ticket, have the owner’s representative initial the addition, stop once more than about 1/4 yd3 has been discharged, and agree at a pre-placement meeting who may authorize water. When the spec bans jobsite water, the producer can batch all design water at the plant and use admixtures on site. Trucks with automated slump monitoring may add water in transit; TxDOT Item 421 4.6.2 requires their reports daily and an automated reading within 1 in of a manual slump.

Extra water also lengthens the time before forms can be loaded, which is covered in our concrete curing time guide. On slab work, ordering a mid-range water reducer at the plant is usually cheaper than rejected loads; compare it against our concrete slab cost per square foot figures.

When is the slump test the wrong test?

The slump test does not apply to non-plastic or non-cohesive concrete, mixes with aggregate over 1 1/2 inches unless sieved, or self-consolidating concrete, per ASTM C143 sections 4.2 and 4.3. Self-consolidating concrete is checked by slump flow under ASTM C1611, with a Visual Stability Index, at the frequency UFGS 03 30 00 section 3.14.3.2 sets for the first two batches and each cylinder set.

  • Slump flow (ASTM C1611): spread diameter from the same cone; TxDOT Item 421 lists 22 to 27 in for precast self-consolidating concrete.
  • Stiff mixes under 1/2 in slump: the C143 result has little meaning; the spec should name another consistency test.
  • Strength: slump is never a substitute for cylinders under ASTM C31 and C39.

Slump checks sit inside the wider testing plan required by IBC Chapter 17 and explained in our special inspections guide, and a floor that will be ground and sealed has its own pricing in our polished concrete cost guide.

How we compiled this

We read the WAQTC field operating procedure for AASHTO T 119 in the WSDOT Materials Manual (January 2026), ASTM’s C143 and C94 abstracts, UFGS 03 30 00 Change 10, TxDOT’s 2024 Item 421, NRMCA CIP 26 and CIP 31, a U.S. Navy Builder training manual and ACI’s catalog and FAQ pages, 12 primary documents in all, accessed November 2026. ACI 117 and ASTM C94 tolerance values are as published in those standards; confirm the edition your contract names. We did not run tests ourselves.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good slump for concrete?

For most commercial work a good slump is 3 to 5 inches, the range NRMCA CIP 31 (2023) gives for most applications and the window ACI 301-20 produces with its 4 inch default and ACI 117 tolerance of plus or minus 1 inch. Slip-form paving needs 2 inches or less, and pumped walls or congested reinforcement may need 7 to 9 inches.

How long does a slump test take?

The test must start within 5 minutes of taking the sample and run from the first scoop to lifting the cone within 2 1/2 minutes, per the AASHTO T 119 field procedure in the WSDOT Materials Manual (January 2026). The cone lift itself takes 5 seconds, plus or minus 2. Measuring adds under a minute, so a technician finishes in about 4 minutes.

Is a 6 inch slump too wet?

A 6 inch slump is too wet only if the specification says so. It is above the ACI 301 default window of 3 to 5 inches, but TxDOT Item 421 Table 9 allows up to 6 inches for bridge slabs and up to 7 inches for columns and thick walls. With a water reducer, ACI 301 permits up to 8 inches when the w/cm limit is met.

Does a higher slump mean weaker concrete?

Higher slump from added water usually means weaker concrete: NRMCA CIP 26 (2023) says water beyond the design amount reduces strength, delays setting and raises cracking risk. Higher slump from a water-reducing admixture usually does not, provided the w/cm stays the same. ASTM C143 notes the slump to strength link is not clearly shown under field conditions, so cylinders decide strength.

Who performs the slump test on a commercial job?

The owner’s testing agency or special inspector usually performs it, using a technician holding ACI Field Testing Technician Grade I or an equivalent. TxDOT Item 421 section 4.8.1 requires ACI certification or a recognized equivalent. The contract should say who pays for retests of failed loads, which is often the contractor or ready-mix supplier, not the owner.

What is the difference between slump and slump flow?

Slump measures how far concrete drops from the 12 inch cone, under ASTM C143. Slump flow, under ASTM C1611, measures how wide self-consolidating concrete spreads after the same cone is lifted, often 22 to 27 inches for precast in TxDOT Item 421. Use slump flow when a mix would collapse in the slump test, above about 9 inches.

Sources

Last reviewed November 2026 by the CB&C Editorial Team. See our editorial standards.

← Back to all articles